Year Mr Gay Eugene Miss Gay Eugene Ms Gay Eugene
1985-1986 – Andrea Fault*
 –
1986-1987 – Lindsey Alexander*
 Lindsey Alexander
1987-1988 Lynn Dickinson (Hillary) Delilah Ada
1988-1989 – Camille Katt
1989-1990 Chuck Delilah Terri Jones
1990-1991 xx Nikki Ontalodge Nita
1991-1992 xx Este Slaughter*
 Wendy
1992-1993 Lonnie*
 Shelle*
 Sherri
1993-1994 Robert Birch Hellin Heels Jo-O (Joanne)
1994-1995 Bruce Genevieve Liz
1995-1996 Dan McGuire Rose Devin Buchanan –
1996-1997   Jessica –
1997-1998 Bob Will Slaughter Jasmine –
1998-1999 – Tokyo Rose Butler –
1999-2000 – Melissa Doll St. James –
2000-2001 Donny Doone Korrinne Snapp Butler –
2001-2002 Edward Dragonstarr Fox Kali*
 Nikita Doll
2002-2003 Theo Doll Vanity Venom –
2003-2004 Dale Twist Rhoda Gravel –
2004-2005 Wayne Vest Karress Ann Slaughter –
2005-2006 JD Twist kink – Charity Twist Kink
2006-2007 Payton Gravel Twist – Marty Storm
2007-2008 Alexander Taylor – Raven Kink
2008-2009 Devon Kink Karen Herr Trinity Kink
2009-2010 John Goforth – –
2010-2011 Topher Doone – –
2011-2012 Cole Anna Rexia Bulemia Charity Dupont
2012-2013 – – –
2013-2014 – – –
2014-2015 – Totallie Devine –
2015-2016 – Glorya Holes Storm –
2016-2017 Edward Dragonstarr Fox Honey Galore –